Joe Matthews / Micah Matthias
Tom Everett Scott
Rachel Troyler
Sarah Lancaster
Sam Phillips
John Eby
Dylan Matthias
Geoffrey Hoffman
Elise
Kaitlyn Sapp
Reporter #1
Chris Van Vliet
Reporter #2
Jeannie Madison
Ypung Rachel Troyler
Madison Blake
Frank Troyer
Dave McConnell
Head Official
Joe Kurak
Disheveled Guy
Dave Durch
Mechanic
Kyle Primous
Bobby Matthews / Bobby Matthias
Thomas Kapanowski
Cashier
Serena Miller
Umpire
Kris Leiter
Mary Anne (Bank Teller)
Mary Anne Prevost
Bobby Double
Trenton Huff
Horse & Buggy Wrangler
Abe M. Yoder
Horse Trainer
Nicole Miller
Buggy Horse
Blaze
Amish Youths Chasing Buggy
Curtis Blackburn
Jason Burroughs
Grungy Guy
Ryan Schultz
Bertha Troyler
Kelly McGillis
Garaway Baseball Team
Kirk Putman
Michah VanFossen
Brandon Weaver
B.J. Schwartz
Benjamin Mason
Brandon Johnson
Zach Huffman
Tyrrell Keim
Jerrod F. Hunt
Joe Haynes
Kim
Nicole Badaan
Seth Miller
Parker Barnhouse
Lydia Troyler
Annie Kitral
Chloe Styles
Katherine DeBoer
Anna Troyler
Marianna Alacchi
Eli Troyler
Ken Strunk
Ed Spencer
Greg Violand
Editor
Brett Hedlund
Stunt Coordinator
Kelleigh Miller
Director
Terry Cunningham
Screenplay
Bryar Freed
Novel
Script Supervisor
Sarah Willgrube
ADR Editor
Martin Quiñones
Still Photographer
Marc Biss
Production Design
Kalleigh Miller
Costume Design
Karen L. Young
Director of Photography
Adam N. White
Casting
Lillian Pyles
Original Music Composer
Jamie Christopherson
Producer
Travis Mann
Property Master
Teresa Strebler
Foley Editor
Avis Stanley
Dialogue Editor
Eric Romero
Set Costumer
Candace N. Brown
First Assistant Director
Derek Rimelspach
Sound Editor
Ashu Boni
George Shamieh
Makeup Artist
Susan R. Prosser
Hairstylist
Liz Duchez
Ryan Villarreal