Jaffrey Pyncheon
George Sanders
Hepzibah Pyncheon
Margaret Lindsay
Blacksmith Hawkins
Harry Cording
Ex-Convict
Michael Mark
Driver
Hal Budlong
Town Gossip
Caroline Frances Cooke
Workman
Kernan Cripps
Jury Foreman
Robert Dudley
Martin Faust
Margaret Fealy
Mrs. Foster
Sibyl Harris
Man Drinking From Cup
Ellis Irving
Clifford Pyncheon
Vincent Price
Man With Rake
P.J. Kelly
Court Bailiff
Colin Kenny
Courtroom Spectator
Ann Kunde
Jane Loofbourrow
Murdock MacQuarrie
Ex-Convict Reading Tribune
Coroner in Courtroom
Nelson McDowell
Mrs. Reynolds
Mira McKinney
Phineas Weed - Jaffrey's Servant
Edgar Norton
Juror
Lon Poff
Phoebe Pyncheon
Nan Grey
Grocer / Juror
Russ Powell
Allen D. Sewall
Prison Guard
Jack C. Smith
Reverend Jeremiah Smith
Hugh Sothern
Jeremiah - Man in Pub
Harry Stubbs
Witness
Claire Whitney
Mr. Wainwright
Harry Woods
Matthew Maule
Dick Foran
Philip Barton
Cecil Kellaway
Fuller
Alan Napier
Gerald Pyncheon
Gilbert Emery
Deacon Arnold Foster
Miles Mander
Judge
Charles Trowbridge
Writer
Nathaniel Hawthorne
Music
Frank Skinner
Director
Joe May
Makeup Artist
Jack Pierce
Director of Photography
Milton Krasner
Sound
Bernard B. Brown
Harold Greene
Lester Cole
Producer
Burt Kelly
Editor
Frank Gross
Set Decoration
Russell A. Gausman
Art Direction
Jack Otterson
Costume Design
Vera West