Waiter
David Bowles
Dr. Doctor Willard Bliss
James Eckhouse
Roscoe Conkling
Sean Mahon
Narrator
Michael Murphy
Reporter
Ted Otis
Silas Boynton
Daniel Pearce
Mary 'Mollie' Garfield
Karina Rchichev
Harry Garfield
Dan Rowland
Joseph Stanley Brown
Joe Weintraub
Lucretia Garfield
Kathryn Erbe
Jim Garfield
Ladislav Gergel
James Garfield
Shuler Hensley
Dr. Reyburn
Logan Hillier
James Blaine
John Hutton
Charles Guiteau
Will Janowitz
Conkling's Valet
Josef Karas
Chester Arthur
Adam LeFevre
Writer
Rob Rapley
Paul Taylor
Candice Millard
Director