Peter Pan
Mary Martin
Mr. Darling / Captain Hook
Cyril Ritchard
Liza
Jacqueline Mayro
Slightly
Edmund Gaynes
Curly
Bill Snowden
Nibs
Carson Woods
First Twin
Benedict Herrman
Second Twin
Luke Halpin
Tootles
David Komoroff
Lion
Richard Wyatt
Ostrich
Joan Tewkesbury
Wendy Grown-up
Peggy Maurer
Narrator
Lynn Fontanne
Black Bill
John Holland
Starkey
Robert Vanselow
Cecco
Richard Winter
Kangaroo
George Zima
Pirate
Frank Lindsay
Frank Marasco
Arthur Partington
Jim Sisco
Kirby Smith
John Smolko
Wendy / Jane
Maureen Bailey
Arthur Tookoian
James B. Welch
Indian
Linda Dangcil
George Lake
Lisa Lang
Diki Lerner
Annabelle Lyon
Robert Piper
Suzanne Rivera
Anne Wallace
Mrs. Darling
Margalo Gillmore
Pirate (uncredited)
Jerry Johnson
Tiger Lily
Sondra Lee
Smee
Joe E. Marks
Nana / Crocodile
Norman Shelly
John
Joey Trent
Michael
Kent Fletcher
Lyricist
Adolph Green
Theatre Play
J.M. Barrie
Songs
Jule Styne
Writer
Jerome Robbins
Director
Vincent J. Donehue
Moose Charlap
Betty Comden
Carolyn Leigh