Maria
Sonia Manzano
Leela
Nitya Vidyasagar
Luis
Emilio Delgado
Bob
Bob McGrath
Gordon
Roscoe Orman
Susan
Loretta Long
Linda
Linda Bove
Gina
Alison Bartlett
Miles
Olamide Faison
Self / Big Bird
Caroll Spinney
Additional Muppets (voice)
Tau Bennett
Gonger / Panicked Purple Monster / ... (voice)
Warrick Brownlow-Pike
Self - Host
Joseph Gordon-Levitt
Dish / Louie / Letter A (voice)
Tyler Bunch
Abby Cadabby (voice)
Leslie Carrara-Rudolph
Rudy (voice)
Frankie Cordero
Betty Lou / Pink Jacket / Little Bird / Prairie Dawn (voice)
Stephanie D'Abruzzo
Don Music / Elmo / Lefty the Salesman / ... (voice)
Ryan Dillon
Julia (voice)
Stacey Gordon
Hoots the Owl (voice)
Christopher Hayes
Captain Vegetable / Ernie / Herry Monster (voice)
Peter Linz
Spencer Lott
Baby Bear / Cookie Monster / Letter Y / Sully / ... (voice)
David Rudman
Mr. Noodle
Bill Irwin
Self
Norah Jones
Nile Rodgers
Sterling K. Brown
Elvis Costello
Meghan Trainor
Whoopi Goldberg
Itzhak Perlman
Patti LaBelle
Gladys the Cow / Mama Bear / Zoe (voice)
Jennifer Barnhart
Goldilocks / Grundgetta / Telly Monster (hand) / ... (voice)
Pam Arciero
Nina
Suki Lopez
Fran Brill
Bert / Grover / Guy Smiley / Harvey Kneeslapper / ... (voice)
Eric Jacobson
Big Bird / The Count / Kermit the Frog / Biff / ... (voice)
Matt Vogel
Alan
Alan Muraoka
Chris / Roosevelt Franklin (voice)
Chris Knowings
Writer
Christine Ferraro