Tom Endler
Jesse Metcalfe
Principal Kinney
Robin Givens
Catherine Thawley
Maria Canals-Barrera
Reverend Jude
Benjamin Ochieng
Marlene
Sadie Robertson
Senior Pastor
Fred Thompson
Pastor Dave Hill
David A.R. White
Peter Kane
Ray Wise
Waiter
Tommy Blaze
Rice Broocks
Susan Stone
Mallory Hardin Brooks
Mrs. Rizzo
Natalie Canerday
Grace Wesley
Melissa Joan Hart
Rev. Dave Double
Ron Clemens
First Teacher
Verda Davenport
Jessica
Abigail Duhon
Goth Girl
Taylor Eaves
Crazy Cat Lady
Kayla Esmond
Frazzled Teacher
Mary Faulkner
Fashionista
Jenn Gotzon Chandler
Gary Habermas
Sunny Barista
Lauren Harper
Salvation Army Lady
Candyce Hinkle
School Attorney
Brad Heller
Mike Huckabee
Bailiff
Andres Hudson
County Clerk
Mark Whitman Johnson
Slacker Kid
Corey Koteras
Prospective Juror
Mario Luna
Male Journalist
Travis McCoy
Simon Boyle
Eamonn McCrystal
Paramedic
Gary Newton
Norma
Vivian Norman
V.P. of Teachers Union
Chanley Painter
Judge Stennis
Ernie Hudson
Teenage Girl
Taylor Quick
Pharmacist
Paige Martin Reynolds
Female Juror
Kimberly Scott
Elizabeth Healy
Gianna Simone
Older Man
John Stiritz
Lee Strobel
Jury Forman
Ryk St. Vincent
Jim Warner Wallace
J. Warner Wallace
Martin's Father
Jesse Wang
The Newsboys
Michael Tait
Brooke Thawley
Hayley Orrantia
Duncan Phillips
Jeff Frankenstein
Jody Davis
Concert Patron (uncredited)
Cara Alvey
Jury Extra (uncredited)
Danny Campbell
Courtroom observer (uncredited)
Gregory Chisley
Medical Staff (uncredited)
Brock Clyburn
Food Truck Patron (uncredited)
Ann Cogswell
Gallery Observer (uncredited)
Margaret Cogswell
Lawyer (uncredited)
Greg Fallon
Walter Wesley
Pat Boone
Protestor (uncredited)
Kenneth Gaddie
Waitress (uncredited)
Latiera Golliday
Extra (uncredited)
Lauren Hall
Courtroom Observer (uncredited)
Mary Handiboe
Paramedic (uncredited)
Bryan Harp
Student (trouble maker) (uncredited)
Spencer Kane Hess
Protester Shaking Jesse Metcalfe Hand (uncredited)
Brent Holt
Supporter (uncredited)
Misty Jezierski
Juror #6 (uncredited)
D. Matt Jordan
Background (uncredited)
Chuck King
Martin Yip
Paul Kwo
Timid Pastor (uncredited)
James Mainard O'Connell
Courtroom Observer / Protester (uncredited)
Star McCann
Angela Sherrill Merriott
Juror (uncredited)
Alanna Hamill Newton
Courtroom Gallery / Protestor (uncredited)
Carmen Patterson
Courtroom Observer / Reporter (uncredited)
Arnold John Popa III
Concert patron (uncredited)
Nicole A. Randall
Classmate (uncredited)
Nokona Redus
Ashley Richardson
Protester (uncredited)
Taylor Robirts
Amy Ryan
Trisha LaFache
Samantha M Shaw
Isaac Slatton
Concert Attendee (uncredited)
Shawn C Smith
Kristina Strava
Lawyer Assistant (uncredited)
Cameron Taylor
Stacey McBryde Valley
Reporter (uncredited)
Mindy Van Kuren
Terri Whitehurst
Don E. Willis
Richard Thawley
Carey Scott
Superintendent Jim Powell
Jon Lindstrom
Writer
Chuck Konzelman
Producer
Casting
Dea Vise
Russell Wolfe
Co-Producer
Matt Shapira
Director
Harold Cronk
Editor
Vance Null
Cary Solomon
Costume Design
Cami Nemanich
Billy DaMota
Production Design
Mitchell Crisp
Grip
Lil-Cliffton Daniels
Director of Photography
Brian Shanley
Original Music Composer
Will Musser
Executive Producer
Bob Katz